How Many Google Reviews Should a Gutter Company Have?
Almost every NJ gutter company is "5 stars"
We rank 227 local gutter firms across more than 300 New Jersey and New York towns, and their Google star ratings are nearly identical: 51% show a flawless 5.0, 90% sit at 4.8 or higher, and only five rate below 4.5. When almost everyone is "excellent," the star stops telling you anything — the theme of our star-rating data study.
Review count is the signal that survives
What actually separates companies is how many people have reviewed them, and here the spread is enormous. The median firm in our data has just 77 Google reviews. Only 14 of the 227 have cracked 500, and just four have topped 1,000:
| Most-reviewed firms in our rankings | Google reviews | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Deegan Roofing | 1,825 | 4.9 |
| Trenton Roofing & Siding | 1,490 | 5.0 |
| Stainless Powerwashing | 1,403 | 5.0 |
| Clearview Washing | 1,030 | 4.9 |
| Spotless Gutter Cleaning & Repair | 935 | 4.8 |
| Splendor Roofing and Gutters | 926 | 5.0 |
Notice what these are: the biggest review piles mostly belong to full-service roofers and power-washing firms that also do gutters, not gutter-only shops. The most-reviewed dedicated gutter specialist we rank is Spotless, at about 935. And every firm here is a genuine local business — we exclude national ad-brands like Ned Stevens and LeafFilter, and toll-free lead-buyers, by policy (see how we rank), because a franchise's review pile says more about its ad budget than the crew on your roof.
How to read a review count
- A 5.0 on 6 reviews is thin — it can be friends and family. A 4.8 on 900 is a track record.
- Look for depth and recency — 200 reviews whose newest is two years old is a company that has slowed down.
- Below ~15 reviews, treat the rating as provisional — not damning, just not yet proven.
- Read the 1- and 2-star reviews first — the pattern in the complaints tells you the real risk better than the average ever will.
Why we rank by review count, not stars
This is exactly why our town-by-town rankings sort by review volume rather than the near-useless star rating — we call it "reading the bar." A company with 400 reviews at 4.8 has earned more trust than a 5.0 with 12, and the ranking should say so. The full method is in how we rank.
See the most-reviewed gutter pros in your town →
FAQ
How many Google reviews should a gutter company have?
There is no hard minimum, but context helps: in our New Jersey data the median gutter firm has about 77 reviews, so anything over ~100 is solid and 500-plus is genuinely rare — only 14 of the 227 firms we track have reached it. Below roughly 15 reviews, treat the rating as provisional rather than proven.
Is a 5-star gutter company always better?
No. In our data 51% of firms show a flawless 5.0 and 98% rate 4.5 or higher, so the star barely separates them. A 5.0 built on six reviews can be friends and family; a 4.8 built on 900 is a real track record. Weigh the review count and read the recent one- and two-star reviews.
Why isn't Ned Stevens or LeafFilter in your rankings?
By policy we rank local specialists, not national ad-brands, franchises, or toll-free lead-buyers like Ned Stevens or LeafFilter, because a franchise's giant review pile reflects its advertising budget more than the crew that shows up at your house. The most-reviewed local firms we do rank top out around 900–1,800 reviews. See how we rank for the full method.
How many gutter companies did you analyze?
These figures come from the 227 distinct local firms we rank across more than 300 New Jersey and New York towns, using their real Google ratings and review counts. It is the set of local specialists that surfaced in our town-by-town research, not a census of every firm in the state.